Wins/Vulture Wins/Quality Starts (Read 476 times)

[Bobby]

Personally I hate vulture wins by the bullpen. Lost a championship to it.

Just a non-binding poll checking interest for changing W to quality starts next year.

[bosox]

The thing about vulture wins is it kind of goes with holds guys,making some of them better value.

there really are not a lot of them but considering we have holds and they do blow many wins getting back the odd one is fine with me.

i have nothing against quality starts except with so many sps already signed and at various costs their values could drop down or rise up
and i am sure nobody would be too happy about high cost guys worth less and other teams having low cost guys now worth more.

i think it would be too big a change.

[Deleted]

Jun 4, 2011 19:56:33 GMT -8 @bosox said:

The thing about vulture wins is it kind of goes with holds guys,making some of them better value.

there really are not a lot of them but considering we have holds and they do blow many wins getting back the odd one is fine with me.

i have nothing against quality starts except with so many sps already signed and at various costs their values could drop down or rise up
and i am sure nobody would be too happy about high cost guys worth less and other teams having low cost guys now worth more.

i think it would be too big a change.

pretty much my thoughts as well. while you have vulture wins or bs wins, you get the same thing with holds as well.

[Deleted]

Jun 4, 2011 18:57:54 GMT -8 Bobby said:

Just a non-binding poll checking interest for changing W to quality starts next year.

This is not a rule change-"a non-binding poll to check interest"

I hate wins as a category, and like quality starts but not sure we really need to change it, relievers are a big piece of this league with the holds factor

[lewjo]

Whoops! Went to tik Keep Wins and hit QS instead.

In this league, I like wins as a category.

[johnnybravo]

I like the W's. When one's pitching staff is as historically unreliable as mine, vulture W's are the best kind. It adds an element of last day finality to it. That sort of thing is what makes this such an interesting league.

[hawkeye5]

Vulture wins count for real. I don't see why we would want to penalize teams for getting them.

[Deleted]

informal poll, but I'd like to change my vote to WINS also

[Yankees]

scoring seems fine to me but always open to give stuff a shot for a year.